Posted by: alok | June 15, 2007

Online Music sharing – what’s the catch?

It’s quite some time since I read Steve Job’s “Thoughts on Music”, and much more time to understand the possible implications of the same. Some of the questions lingering in my mind are:

  • Is online sharing of music (or any media files) a copyright violation?
  • Why is that music companies themselves sell unprotected CDs (without DRM), thereby allowing pirated copies to be made?
  • However, at the same time, they do not miss a chance to sue any company involved in distributing the music online?
  • Do all the ‘dot coms’ of the world who allow you to play music online (streaming) or downloading have obtained the rights from the music companies?
  • Why is that music companies are asking Microsoft and Apple to DRM protect their songs sold on iTunes or Zune, thereby reducing interoperability – but at the same time do not enforce a song ripped on a “Sony” CD be played only on a “Sony” music system and allow it to be played on music systems developed by Samsung or Philips or even all PCs? Imagine a world, where I have to purchase one music system for every different CD label..!!!
  • If I am allowed to copy and play any song on an Apple iPod, what purpose does DRM protected songs on iTunes online music library serve?
  • If I purchase a genuine CD from a music store – I can make innumerable copies of the same on any number of PCs (whether I or my friends or friends’ friends own). So is it a copyright violation, and can I be sued by BMG, Universal, or backhome T-Series, HMV etc.?
  • Or for that matter, if I make copies of the song purchased from a genuine legal channel on my Creative Zen Nano player, my music system, my laptop, my backup hard-disk, my mobile phone – then am I doing some offence?
  • What if my music-player allows me to record songs being broadcasted on FM radio, and I record the same?
  • How is that YouTube (and the likes) allow users to upload any content and not get challenged in the court of law? Just by saying that its “user-generated” and asking the user to click on a check-box saying “You are responsible for any content that you upload” absolve “YouTube’s?
  • If YouTube can be held guilty by providing a medium for sharing music, shouldn’t Xerox be held responsible for developing photo-copier machines to make innumerable copies of printed books, or for that matter can we held Microsoft responsible for providing ‘Ctrl-C’, ‘Ctrl-V’ feature, or can we hold HP, Samsung, LG etc. to develop CD-writers ?
  • If Mr. Jobs himself thinks that only 3% of the songs stored on iPods are genuine purchased from iTunes store – so is his company responsible for encouraging piracy?
  • Not long ago, Napsters, Kaza, Torrents were sued millions of dollars for PTP music sharing – so how come in the Web 2.0 era the so-called “user-generated” content has escaped the radar?

Can anyone with some knowledge of intricacies of the vagaries of copyright and music piracy enlighten me by providing the answers to the above?

Advertisements

Responses

  1. I must say, pertinent and thought-provoking question!! Good to see you back:)

  2. Hey, you should write more often….I used to follow your blog some time back….but then you slowed down a lot…

  3. Don’t have much idea about the question but i must say you and your blogging motivated me for blogging. Try to visit mine if get time…:)

  4. Don’t have much idea about the question but i (http://amitkumarsingh.wordpress.com/) must say you and your blogging motivated me for blogging. Try to visit mine if get time…:)

  5. Alok, it seems you have been motivator for most of us. We are dying to hear more from you.

  6. When in Brisbane don’t forget to buy party pills. Fantastic blog! I genuinely love how it is easy on my eyes and also the details are well written. I am wondering how. I might be notified whenever a new post has been made.. I have subscribed to your rss feed which need to do the trick! Have a nice day!

  7. Hi dear, normally I never publish comments on personal blogs however right now I am afraid I absolutely have to do it. A few days ago I decided to install the newest version of the Apple Safari web browser and your web blog doesn’t render properly anymore. Right now the header hides part of the text and I just can’t see it. I had the same trouble with my herbal incense reviews Internet blog and I was able to fix it by editing the HTML code. Can you please fix it? Thanks in advance! Please excuse my English, it’s not mother language. I’m German 🙂

  8. Thank you so much for your posting. It was very helpful. I hope to see more posts from you in the future.

  9. Pretty great post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I’ve truly loved browsing your blog posts. After all I will be subscribing for your rss feed and I’m hoping you write once more soon! Come on http://tropaadet.dk/melonieskinner4916081830

  10. merhaba harika bir site bursa ikinci el eşya dükkanımıza bekleriz


Leave a Reply to amitkumarsingh Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: